Columbia City drops fire station plan for Bundy Park after 288 signatures

The council voted 4-0 in September to stop pursuing a fire station in Jim Bundy Memorial Park. Residents petitioned against it, and the state said fire engines could not get direct Highway 30 access.

A proposal to put a fire station in Jim Bundy Memorial Park is dead for the second time in three years. The Columbia City Council voted 4-0 on Sept. 17 “to cease all activities pursuing a fire station in Bundy Park,” according to the meeting minutes.

The vote came after residents delivered a petition with 288 signatures, a group of them canvassed about 30 percent of the city’s households, and the state told the city that fire engines could not have the direct Highway 30 access the plan depended on. The Tribune pieced the sequence together from 10 sets of city minutes going back to 2023.

What Was Proposed

Columbia River Fire & Rescue has no station in Columbia City. At a council workshop on May 29, Fire Chief Eric Smythe said the district is looking at another station because the county is growing, the St. Helens station is 100 years old, and response times can be affected by train traffic, according to the workshop minutes. “The ask of Columbia City is for land and the ask of ODOT is for direct access to HWY 30,” the minutes say. After that the district would look for grants. If it needed a bond, the measure would go to its whole taxing district.

Simon Ebert, a Columbia City resident and Portland Community College architectural design student, presented a concept for a station in the park that he said was drawn to fit a residential neighborhood and “remove as few trees as possible.”

In written answers attached to those minutes, the fire district said Columbia City accounts for about 5 percent of its incidents, between 280 and 350 calls a year. A station there would cover the city and parts of Deer Island and Tide Creek Road, and the district estimated about half of its responses would be inside the city limits.

Mayor Alexander Reed told residents in June that response times in the city are “currently around eight minutes” and that the chief had said a local station would cut that to four, according to the June 18 minutes. He also said “no decisions have been made.”

The Opposition

Bundy Park is 2.86 wooded acres at E Street and Highway 30, known for its trillium, with a picnic shelter and trails, according to the city’s parks page. Neighbors told the council the trees buffer them from the highway. Garett Greig, who said he lives on the park’s border, told the council in June that the station would be next to his side yard.

On July 16 more than a dozen residents spoke, according to the minutes. Celeste Smith presented a “Save Bundy Park” petition with 288 signatures. Jackie Zieglar held up a drawing by her young daughter of the two of them walking through the park. Several speakers asked the fire district to show data that a station is needed. One, Rebecca Pickering, said it was important to consider the station because the fire department needs to modernize. The council voted 4-0 to delay its discussion.

At a workshop that day, Reed said there were really two questions: whether residents want a fire station at all, and whether they want part of Bundy Park used for one. Councilor Connie Quick said donated land would count as an in-kind contribution the district could use in grant applications. On Aug. 10 the council agreed to survey residents in the September newsletter, the minutes say.

The Highway

The survey never went out. On Aug. 20, Reed reported that the Oregon Department of Transportation had told the city access onto Highway 30 between A Street and E Street is restricted. City Administrator Kim Karber said that after talking with the agency, “the access is restricted and there are no exceptions, not even for fire stations,” and that earlier council discussions had treated the lack of direct highway access as “a deal breaker,” according to the minutes. The council voted 4-0 to put the questionnaire and the project on hold.

At the same meeting, Alexandria Smith reported on the petition effort. Over three months, she said, volunteers surveyed 251 households, about 30 percent of the city: 227 opposed the station and 24 favored it. James Bundy spoke for his family and said none of them advocates for the station, and that the park should stay “as a place for the community to enjoy nature,” as his grandfather Jim would have wanted.

A month later the council ended it. Councilor Lyle Bluhm said that in the future “it would be nice to have all the right information at the right time for decision making.” Police Chief Jerry Bartolomucci told the council the idea had come from the fire department and been brought to previous councils, and that the information was “vague/sparse when originally presented, which may have led to it being tabled in the past.” He said the fire department should research access and other details before presenting again.

The First Time

The fire district first brought the idea to the council on Feb. 16, 2023, when then-Chief Joel Medina described a station staffed around the clock and said Columbia City sits in a “pocket” between the St. Helens and Rainier stations, according to that meeting’s minutes. An architect working for the district showed a schematic of a station at Bundy Park.

The next month the city administrator at the time told the council that the city attorney had confirmed the city could legally donate land for a station, and that a representative of the Bundy family supported the concept, the March 2023 minutes say. The park is named for Jim Bundy, a former city public works superintendent who, the family representative said, served 11 years in the fire service.

On July 20, 2023, resident Wendy Wells turned in a petition with 208 signatures opposing “giving away Bundy Park freely,” according to the minutes. The city ran community surveys on the idea that spring and summer, according to later 2023 minutes. The council’s minutes for the rest of that year do not mention the proposal again.

What Comes Next

Nothing is pending. Two of the residents who spoke in July, Mike Rasczewski and Logan Gilbert-Renner, were elected to the council on Nov. 3. Rasczewski spoke about his concerns with donating park land. Gilbert-Renner said the fire department needed to do more to show a station is needed in Columbia City, and his candidate statement in the city’s October newsletter listed “preserving our parks” first among his priorities.

The city’s new Parks Master Plan, adopted in February, calls for a playground and a sport court at Bundy Park in later years. It does not mention a fire station.

This account is drawn from the city’s meeting minutes, including the fire district’s statements recorded there. The Tribune has not interviewed the fire district for this story.