,

Levy failed. Now St. Helens may charge for police calls.

St. Helens’ Nov. 18 work session lists an interim police chief during Chief Matthew Smith’s leave of absence, a proposed police response fee, and converting an officer job to a records post. Columbia City’s council discusses its failed levy Nov. 19. Neither city posted details.

Ten days after voters in St. Helens and Columbia City turned down police levies by wide margins, both city councils meet next week with policing on the agenda, and the St. Helens list is the longer one: an interim police chief, a proposed fee for police responses, and a plan to turn a sworn officer’s job into a civilian records position.

The St. Helens council’s Wednesday, Nov. 18 work session, at 3 p.m. in council chambers and on Zoom, includes three police items in a row, according to the agenda: a proposal to “convert 1.0 FTE Police Officer to 1.0 FTE Records & Evidence Specialist,” presented by Police Chief Matthew Smith at 3:20 p.m.; “Discuss Proposed Police Response Fee” at 4:05 p.m.; and, at 4:15 p.m., “Appointment of Lt. Treat as Interim Police Chief during Chief Smith’s Leave of Absence.” The agenda gives no dates for the leave and no description of the fee. The 160-page meeting packet contains no material for any of the three items.

Columbia City’s council held a Nov. 9 workshop with a single item, “Police Levy,” per its agenda, and has “Police Levy” under new business again for its regular meeting Thursday, Nov. 19, at 6 p.m. at City Hall, 1840 Second St., along with a discussion of “illegal burning outside the Columbia City allowed open burn periods,” according to the agenda. The city posted no staff report on either.

What the Voters Said

St. Helens Measure 5-312, a five-year levy of $1.46 per $1,000 of assessed value that the city said would keep the department at its current size, failed 4,526 to 1,611 in the county’s Nov. 12 updated count, about 74 percent no. Columbia City Measure 5-313, which would have raised the town’s police levy from 90 cents to $1.95 per $1,000, failed 728 to 453, about 62 percent no. Both cities had said in the voters’ pamphlet what a no vote would mean: St. Helens that it would have to cut police staffing or find other revenue after bridge financing runs out June 30, 2027, and Columbia City that it “will be required to reduce police services,” as the Tribune reported before the election (5-312, 5-313).

St. Helens by the Numbers

Police is the largest line in the St. Helens general fund. The 2026-27 budget carries $4,714,500 for police personnel and $762,500 for police materials and services, and the department spent $1,168,495 in the first quarter ending Sept. 30, about 21 percent of the year’s total, according to the finance division’s quarterly report in the work session packet. The report notes the city is running on furloughs and “one less FTE” in utility billing, and that the police station improvement project is under construction.

The same night, the council’s regular session at 7 p.m. will vote on moving $301,301 from contingency to debt service inside the Public Safety Fund. The city owes $1,301,300.21 in arbitrage rebate, a federal requirement when bond proceeds earn more interest than the bonds pay, and budgeted only $1 million for it, per the council memo. A separate monthly report in the packet flags a police CJIS audit, the FBI’s Criminal Justice Information Services security review, scheduled for Nov. 19, with “MFA and broader police technology readiness” listed as “key compliance concerns.”

Columbia City by the Numbers

Columbia City budgeted $455,171 for police this year and had spent $140,788 through Oct. 31, leaving 69 percent, according to the expense report in the council’s Nov. 19 packet. The department’s October report from Chief Jerry Bartolomucci lists two officers and a reserve officer, Sgt. Mansheim, who handles evidence and the Mark43 records system and gave 24 hours of patrol and traffic enforcement during the month. The department logged 97 activities in October: 23 premise checks, nine follow-ups, eight traffic stops, six animal complaints, six civil enforcement calls, five suspicious-circumstance calls, four traffic complaints, three agency assists, two runaway juveniles, two frauds, two welfare checks, one death investigation, one domestic dispute, one juvenile sex crime, two traffic crashes, and a handful of others.

The city has paid for its police department with a voter-approved levy since 2011, and the current 90-cent levy expires after the 2026-27 tax year, the city said in its explanatory statement. The expiring levy was already being supplemented with general fund money, which the statement called unsustainable.

What to Watch

In St. Helens, the questions the agenda leaves open are who is running the department and for how long, what a “police response fee” would charge and to whom, and whether converting an officer position is the first of the cuts the city warned about. In Columbia City, the question is whether the council puts a levy back on a 2027 ballot, with the current one expiring, or starts cutting. Both meetings are open to the public; St. Helens offers Zoom.